|
|
AIDS Treatment News
AIDS Trestment News
July 17, 1998
Contents:
For subscription, donation and editorial information and to read our Statement of Purpose, visit AIDS Treatment News' page here at The Body.
Efavirenz (Sustiva) May Equal or Exceed Protease Inhibitor in Initial Antiretroviral Combination
by John S. James
|
|
One of the most important treatment developments at the 12th
World AIDS Conference (Geneva, June 28 - July 3) was the
report of new phase III data showing that efavirenz (brand
name Sustiva, formerly known as DMP-266), used in combination
with other treatment, may suppress viral load at least as
well as the protease inhibitor indinavir (Crixivan®) in the
equivalent combination with nucleoside reverse transcriptase
inhibitors. The data was from a head-to-head comparison trial
in volunteers with little or no previous antiretroviral
treatment. Efavirenz is still experimental; an application
for marketing was submitted to the FDA by developer DuPont
Pharmaceuticals (formerly DuPont Merck) on June 11, 1998, and
to the European Union on June 29; a Canadian application is
also being submitted.
Of course much remains to be learned about the benefits and
drawbacks of each antiretroviral treatment, but a widespread
consensus at the conference seemed to accept efavirenz
combinations as now "on the table" for consideration among
other major treatment options, which until now have mostly
been built around protease inhibitors. Efavirenz is a non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NNRTI), like
nevirapine or delavirdine.
The following research reports were presented at Geneva:
- The most noteworthy result was a comparison of viral load
reduction with efavirenz plus AZT plus 3TC, vs. a standard-of-care control group treated with indinavir plus AZT plus
3TC; data were available for up to 24 weeks of treatment.
This study assigned 150 patients to each arm, all of them
treatment naive to NNRTIs, protease inhibitors, and 3TC.
Volunteers had to have viral load over 10,000 copies, and CD4
count over 50.
The efavirenz combination suppressed viral load to below 400
copies in a significantly higher proportion of the volunteers
than the control arm, at all time points between week 2 and
week 24. And fewer patients dropped out of the efavirenz
study arm due to adverse events, suggesting that the side
effects may have been less of a problem than with the
standard-of-care treatment.
- While longer-term followup is not yet available from this
study, there are 72-week results from a different trial,
which tested efavirenz in combination with indinavir. The
proportion of volunteers with viral load below 400 copies
peaked at week 16 but was still very good at week 72 (the
exact percentages depend greatly on how one accounts for
missing data -- an issue we will cover separately in AIDS
Treatment News). These volunteers were also NNRTI and
protease inhibitor naive when they started the trial; their
baseline viral load was over 20,000 copies, and their
baseline CD4 count was 100 to 500. This 72-week report was
based on over 40 study volunteers who have been on the
treatment that long.
- Much less information is available for patients who are
more heavily pre-treated. But in two studies presented at
Geneva, either efavirenz plus indinavir, or efavirenz plus
nelfinavir, vs. the protease inhibitor alone, was added to
ongoing antiretroviral therapy with two nucleoside analogs.
All these volunteers had received the nucleoside analogs for
at least eight weeks before they added the new drugs. An
analysis of the first 184 patients in this trial showed a
statistically significant advantage of the four drugs over
the three drugs, in the proportion of persons whose viral
load was suppressed to below 50 copies, the cutoff for the
test which was used.
- Several other efavirenz studies were presented in Geneva -- including combinations with other drugs, and also including a
small study showing that efavirenz plus other antiretrovirals
successfully reduced HIV levels in cerebrospinal fluid to
below 400 copies, the limit of quantification of the test
used, in all eight patients tested.
- According to DuPont Pharmaceuticals, common side effects of
efavirenz include rash, nausea, dizziness, diarrhea,
headache, and insomnia -- with the incidence of severe skin
rash under one percent. Due to birth defects in an animal
study, the drug should only be used in pregnancy if the
benefit to the mother outweighs the risk to the fetus. In the
trial comparing efavirenz plus AZT plus 3TC, vs. indinavir
plus AZT plus 3TC, dizziness was significantly more common in
the efavirenz arm (9% vs. 1%); significantly less common were
nausea (10% vs. 22%) and vomiting. Most side effects were
moderate and lasted less than two weeks.
Comment
One concern about efavirenz is that it may be unlikely to
work in patients who have already developed resistance to
either nevirapine or delavirdine, the two NNRTI drugs
currently approved in the U.S. The three drugs of this class
appear to be cross resistant, due to a few mutations,
especially K103N. It is particularly important to use any
NNRTI correctly, and in a maximally suppressive regimen, to
minimize the chance of developing resistant HIV. (In the
future it might be possible to extend the usefulness of this
class of drugs, by developing an antiretroviral which is
particularly effective against virus with the K103N mutation.
But no such drug is available yet.)
With the protease-inhibitor-containing regimens which are now in common use, physicians have noticed that even when
patients "fail" virologically, they often continue to do well
clinically; virological failure (rebound of viral load,
although usually not all the way to baseline) has not
necessarily caused clinical failure. But no one knows if this
will also happen with efavirenz. Each different class of
drugs forces HIV to develop very different mutations. It is
possible that some of the mutations causing viral resistance
to protease inhibitors might also cause the virus to become
less harmful; but even if this does turn out to be true for
protease inhibitors, it might not apply to other drugs.
With protease inhibitors, the first hint of this effect was
seen in an early indinavir trial, where patients were given
that protease inhibitor alone at a dose which is now known to
be too low. At first the median viral load went down, and the
median CD4 count rose, as expected. Then resistance
developed, and the viral load came back up. However, the CD4
count did not go back down, but remained up. It may be worth
asking whether or not CD4 count increases are similarly
sustained when HIV develops resistance to efavirenz.
Meanwhile, this question does not argue against efavirenz,
since patients who start that drug would presumably switch to
a protease-inhibitor regimen anyway if the first treatment
failed. They would not be left on a failing efavirenz
regimen.
For More Information
Efavirenz is currently available through expanded access
programs; for more information, call the Sustiva Expanded
Access Program, 800-998-6854 (8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through
Friday, from the U.S. or Canada) or in Europe call +44 (0)
1462 488263.
Additional information about the Geneva efavirenz
presentations is available on the World Wide Web. See "Geneva
Conference: Finding Information on the Web and Elsewhere
," in
this issue of AIDS Treatment News.
|
Viral Resistance Overview
by John S. James
|
|
Just before the 12th World AIDS Conference, researchers met
at Lake Maggiore, Italy, for the 2nd International Workshop
on HIV Drug Resistance and Treatment Strategies, June 24-27,
1998. There were well over 150 presentations, divided into
seven workshop sessions:
- New antiretrovirals;
- Mechanisms of antiretroviral resistance;
- Relationship between phenotype, genotype, and clinical
response;
- Combination therapy and its failure;
- Pathogenesis, dynamics, and transmission;
- Immune reconstitution; and
- Long-term suppression/eradication strategies.
We did not attend this highly technical meeting, which is
limited mainly to those who are giving research
presentations. But some of the major themes which emerged
were summarized at the much larger Geneva conference by Dr.
John W. Mellors. He noted several take-home messages:
- Second-generation protease inhibitors that are active
against resistant HIV, in laboratory tests at least, are also
active against wild-type virus, and are headed for phase III
studies (large clinical trials).
- New resistance mutations have been reported -- including a
new kind of resistance mutation, a triple serine (S-S-S)
around position 69 in the RT (reverse transcriptase) gene,
caused by a doubling or insertion of codons in the gene, not
by a substitution as is the case with the resistance
mutations known so far. This S-S-S mutation, when combined
with certain others, causes high-level resistance to AZT,
d4T, and 3TC, and some increase in resistance to abacavir
(1592), but it does not have much effect on ddI or ddC.
- In several retrospective studies in treatment-experienced
patients, baseline phenotypic or genotypic resistance testing
predicted response to new therapy -- an important step toward
validating the usefulness of these tests, although
prospective studies are still needed.
- Viral rebound can occur even with wild-type virus (with no
known resistance mutations). Apparently this means that drug
failure often happens for reasons other than drug resistance.
- An important public-health concern is that drug-resistant
HIV -- including viruses which are resistant to many drugs -- is
being transmitted.
We will provide additional information on resistance in our
ongoing coverage.
Meanwhile, you can hear Dr. Mellors' presentation on the
Webcast or on audio tape (see "Geneva Conference: Finding Information on the Web and Elsewhere
," in this issue).
|
Fusion Inhibitors, T-20; Chemokine Variants; Tat and Interferon Antibodies: Gallo Describes Three New Treatment Approaches
by John S. James
|
|
On July 2 virologist Robert C. Gallo, M.D., told a plenary
session of the 12th World AIDS Conference how growing
knowledge of the life cycle of HIV has led to three
antiretroviral approaches entirely different from treatments
in use today.
I. Fusion inhibitors. The CD4 molecule on the surface of
certain cells (such as the T-helper cell) is often thought of
as the receptor which allows HIV to enter the cell. But Dr.
Gallo views the chemokine receptors (CCR5, CXCR4, and some
others) as the real target of the virus. The CD4 receptor is
usually necessary as well; it interacts with gp-120, a
protein on HIV, to expose gp-41, another HIV protein,
allowing a small part of gp-41 to penetrate the cell wall and
cause fusion of the cell and viral membranes. Dr. Gallo cited
recent publication of X-ray crystallography research which
has given the most detailed picture yet of the of the virus-cell interaction (for a non-technical description, see
"Scientists Take First Picture of AIDS Virus Attacking Cell"
by Nicholas Wade, The New York Times June 18, 1998, page 1 of
the national edition).
This complex process of cell fusion may offer many potential
targets for drugs. Dr. Gallo cited T-20, being developed by
Trimeris, Inc., as a potential treatment based on this
approach which is already in clinical trials, and noted that
viral load drops faster than with most other antiretrovirals.
[Note: For background on T-20, see AIDS Treatment News #293, April 17, 1998.]
II. Chemokines. Dr. Gallo discussed three chemokines (rantes,
MIP-1 alpha, and MIP-1 beta) which interact with the
receptors CCR5 or CXCR4. There are both theoretical and
epidemiological reasons to believe that these chemokines have
antiretroviral effects; for an example of the latter, persons
who have been exposed to HIV many times but remain uninfected
have been found to have unusually high levels of these
substances. But using the chemokines themselves as therapy
could be problematic, due to their normal function of cell
signaling; they usually provide a pro-inflammatory signal,
which may not be wanted, and which might stimulate increased
HIV production. For this reason some researchers have
discounted chemokines as potential therapy. But Dr. Gallo
pointed out that the cell signaling and the antiretroviral
action are two different effects -- and chemical variants of
the natural chemokines can inhibit HIV infection without
causing the cell signaling. These chemokine variants could
potentially provide a new class of antiretroviral treatments.
III. Antibodies against tat and alpha interferon. Dr. Gallo
believes (as do most HIV researchers) that HIV kills some T-cells directly -- but that the larger loss is because even the
uninfected T-cells do not proliferate properly. Dr. Gallo
believes that part of the problem with the uninfected cells
is caused by overproduction of alpha interferon (a natural
inhibitor of cell proliferation) in HIV disease. Another
cause of the abnormal lack of proliferation of uninfected
cells may be the tat protein, which is produced by HIV and
may have various harmful effects; Dr. Gallo cited recent
evidence that high levels of antibodies against tat correlate
with patients doing better. Also, in laboratory tests,
removing tat and excessive alpha interferon from cell
cultures can restore T-cell proliferation to normal.
A way to develop a treatment based on this mechanism would be
to make a vaccine which would cause the body to produce
antibodies against tat and against alpha interferon (to
reduce the alpha interferon level to normal -- and to reduce
the level of tat as much as possible, since it has no normal
function in the body). The vaccine would contain chemical
variants of tat and of alpha interferon, designed to cause
antibody production. Such a vaccine might be given several
times a year -- perhaps also with HIV antigen (to stimulate an
HIV-specific T-helper response) to keep the virus under
control. Dr. Gallo noted that the cost of such a treatment
could be low enough to allow widespread use in developing
countries.
Note: Dr. Gallo's talk will be available through 1999 at
http://www.webcast.aids98.org. The talk, titled "How HIV Functions, Multiplies, and Causes Disease: Possible New Approaches to Therapy," is within the plenary, "Biomedical
Advances in HIV Research," Thursday July 2. For those who
prefer to purchase an audio tape, the tape number for this
plenary is PL4. See "Geneva Conference: Finding Information on the Web and Elsewhere," in this issue.
|
Geneva Conference: Finding Information on the Web and Elsewhere
by John S. James
|
|
If you want more detailed information from the Geneva
conference than you can get by reading newsletters or going
to lectures, panel discussions, or teleconferences that may
be available in your area, the best source by far at this
time is the World Wide Web (often available today in public
libraries, if you do not have other access). The four main
kinds of conference information on the Web are: Searchable
abstracts; Webcast audio lectures; Online summaries by
reporters (some of them book length), and Miscellaneous
(information available through various official and
unofficial sites, including extended abstracts for selected
presentations, and email discussion lists on certain
conference topics). All of these resources are available
without charge.
Later there will also be another Geneva conference
information resource -- a CD-ROM with abstracts, text of some
plenary talks, updated extended summaries, and several
thousand slides. These disks will be expensive, 250 Swiss
franks (about $175) -- probably necessary to cover the cost of
preparing a labor-intensive document which will have a
limited market. (You can order the 12th World AIDS Conference
Update CD-ROM from Congrex Sweden AB, fax 011-46-8-661-8155.)
Also note that the abstracts as submitted will almost
certainly be added to AIDSLINE, and show up in future
searches of that database.
In addition, audio tapes of about 130 oral sessions are
available for purchase, at $11 each (with quantity
discounts); call Convention Cassettes Unlimited, 800-776-5454
(U.S., toll-free), or 760-773-4498, between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m.
Pacific time Monday through Friday; ask for an order form for
tapes of the 12th World AIDS Conference.
Before retrieving detailed conference information, it helps
to know a little about how this meeting was organized, and
how the abstracts and sessions were numbered. The major
official conference presentations were divided into four
tracks: Track A, Basic Science; Track B, Clinical Science and
Care; Track C, Epidemiology, Prevention and Public Health;
and Track D, Social and Behavioral Science. (While officially
equal, in practice Track B usually gets the most emphasis at
the World AIDS Conference, and Track D the least.)
The abstracts are referenced with 5-digit numbers. The first
number is the day of presentation ("1" is Monday June 29, "5"
is Friday July 3, and "6" means that the abstract was
accepted for publication only but not given an oral or poster
presentation slot. Many oral talks also appear as posters,
sometimes on a different day; where appropriate, a reference
may include both the oral session number and the abstract
number. The important Late Breaker talks, and Late Breaker
publication-only abstracts, are numbered like other
abstracts, with the talks also identified as "LB 1" through
"LB 24;" all were presented in two simultaneous sessions on
the last day of the conference, while their abstracts were
presented on earlier days. In addition, there were community
symposia and other talks outside of the four major tracks;
these do not have abstracts, but many of them are available
on the Webcast or by audio tape.
Here are the major Geneva conference resources available
today on the Web:
Searchable Abstracts
All 6,000 abstracts accepted by the conference are online at
the official Web site, http://www.aids98.ch. You can search
by any word or words in the abstracts, and read or print all
or some of the abstracts you find. The search software works
quite well. But there are some problems users should know
about.
Note: The following instructions apply at this time (July
14). The site may be changed later.
The main problem now is the difficulty in finding the
abstract search function on the official Conference Web site;
you have to know where to look. After going to
http://www.aids98.ch, select "Build your own Programme" (a bar on the left side of the screen). That will take you to another page from which you can select "Online Search
Programme." [Note: This link may be difficult to see. It is
just below the heading, "Build your own Programme based on
the Abstracts."]
If this is your first time, you will need to follow the
instructions and create a user name and password in order to
reach the abstracts; for later searches, it will be faster if
you remember your name and password -- but if not, you can make
up another. If the system says that your user name and
password are unacceptable, try another; the name is probably
already in use by somebody else. (The ostensible reason for
having a password is that this system was set up primarily
for use before and during the conference, to prepare an
itinerary of presentations to see at the meeting. The system
keeps the itinerary for each user, allowing you to come back
later and add more items to it.)
There are instructions for doing the search, but you may not
need them. Just select "Standard Search," and you can type
one word which will be searched anywhere in the abstracts.
Then select "View All Titles" or "View Full Abstracts,"
depending on which you want to see. It is often useful to
look at the titles first.
Unfortunately you can only print 10 titles or abstracts at a
time -- unless you put them into your itinerary, which then
allows printing of up to 200 at a time. This is the only use
we ever had for the itinerary function.
Be aware that the abstracts were submitted on paper forms and
then read by an optical scanner -- a machine which never works
perfectly. Many typographical errors were introduced by the
scanning process. Apparently there was not time or money to
hire technical editors to read through all of the originals
and scanned copies to make corrections; a spelling checker
would have been problematic, since it is probably better to
leave all the errors than to correct just the obvious (and
less serious) ones which a spelling checker could find.
The online abstract search is supported by an unrestricted
educational grant from Abbott Laboratories.
Comment
A way to reduce the scanning-error problem at future
conferences is to give presenters the option of submitting
their abstracts by email. Of course paper abstracts must
still be accepted, as many will not have computer access, and
others will have graphics or formulas not well suited to the
computer formats provided. It would also help greatly if
computer printouts of all accepted abstracts could be
returned to the authors for optional corrections -- allowing
them to update their content and data as well, weeks or
months after the original submission deadline, making the
entire conference record that much more current.
While thanking the pharmaceutical sponsors who make this
information distribution possible, we also note that valuable
data is being generated -- potentially exclusive access to
detailed information about what everyone in the world is
searching for in the online World AIDS Conference abstracts.
(The same searches can be done using a CD-ROM which was given
without additional charge to attendees who requested it, and
then no central data is generated.) The password system makes
the data collection cleaner, since most people will use the
same name each time and the records of their searches can be
linked together. Since the individuals are not identified,
privacy issues are minimal. The main practical concern is
that the requirement to go through a "front door" and use a
password makes the process less convenient for users. [Note: the 12th World AIDS Conference is not collecting information about user searches of the abstracts. But the password system which is
in place as we go to press does make access more difficult than
otherwise necessary.]
"Webcast" Audio Lectures and Slides
About 30 to 50 lectures a day were videotaped and are being
placed on the World Wide Web, where they will remain until
the end of 1999. Free telephone technical support is
available (but only for one month after the conference) if
you need help in setting up the software; call 404-836-2186
between 4 a.m. and 5 p.m. Eastern time. This important
"Webcast" system is supported by Gilead Sciences.
Whoever selected the lectures for this broadcast has done a
good job in picking some of the medically important ones. But
Track D (Social and Behavioral Science) was not recorded on
some days, due to technical limitations. While some lectures
were placed online locally within hours of presentation,
others which were recorded are not yet online, apparently
because of the wait for the master videotapes to clear U.S.
customs.
This system allows users to receive audio recordings -- plus
still photos of the accompanying slides, which do help in
following the lectures. The slides do not reproduce well,
however, so fine details and small writing are lost.
We did have some technical hassles setting up our computer to
use this system; however, all of them involved standard
computer technology, not the Webcast site specifically. Users
will not be dependent on the Webcast technical help desk,
which is scheduled to close soon. Those who need assistance
can ask anyone who knows enough about their computer to
download the "Real Player" software package and get it
running on their Web browser. Once it is set up, the system
is easy to use.
Online Summaries, and Other Information
The online conference summaries provide the most accessible,
in-depth reports of the conference -- the easiest to obtain and
the easiest to understand. Since this information is still
changing rapidly, we have not listed the Web sites here, but
are maintaining links at our AIDS Treatment News Internet
Directory site, http://www.aidsnews.org (usually
"aidsnews.org" is enough to get you there). At this site,
select the 12th World AIDS Conference section.
|
AIDS Diarrhea: Phase III Trial Recruiting in Over 30 U.S. Sites
|
|
Persons with AIDS who have diarrhea (from any cause,
including side effects of other drugs) which has lasted 14
days or more may be eligible for a study of PROVIR (SP-303), an experimental drug derived from a plant long used in
South America to treat diarrhea. This drug, being developed
by Shaman Pharmaceuticals, is believed to work differently
than diarrhea medicines in common use, to directly reduce
abnormal flow of water into the intestines.
This study requires six days of inpatient treatment, followed
by 21 days of outpatient treatment for those who respond to
the drug. Three quarters of the volunteers will receive the
active drug in various doses and formulations; one quarter
will receive a placebo.
Volunteers must be at least 18, meet the criteria for AIDS
and be on a stable antiviral regimen, have a stool weight of
at least 300 grams per day, and not be pregnant or lactating.
They must not have been in a trial of another experimental
drug within 30 days, nor received treatment for an intestinal
infection within 14 days. There are some additional medical
criteria.
Shaman Pharmaceuticals, Inc., of South San Francisco, works
with traditional healers to discover drugs in plants that
already are in human use -- giving it a better success rate in
drug discovery than other companies which screen plants at
random. Unlike some companies, Shaman does not try to patent
the plants themselves -- and it takes steps to return value to
the communities from which its discoveries are derived. It
is also testing an oral drug for systemic fungal infection,
and several potential treatments for type II diabetes.
Research sites are located in the following area: Arizona
(Phoenix, Scottsdale); California (Los Angeles, Palo Alto,
San Francisco, West Hollywood); District of Columbia; Florida
(Coral Gables, Maitland, Miami, Orlando, Tampa); Georgia
(Atlanta, Decatur); Illinois (Oak Park); Indiana
(Indianapolis); Louisiana (Kenner, New Orleans);
Massachusetts (Boston); Maryland (Baltimore); Minnesota
(Minneapolis, St. Paul); Michigan (Detroit); Missouri (St.
Louis); North Carolina (Raleigh); New Jersey (Union); New
York (Brooklyn, New York City); Puerto Rico (Ponce, San
Juan); Texas (Houston, San Antonio); Washington (Seattle).
For more information about the PROVIR diarrhea trial, call
NCGS & Associates, 843-723-9555.
|
San Francisco: Geneva Conference Review, July 22
|
|
On Wednesday, July 22, the University of California AIDS
Research Institute will present "The 12th World AIDS
Conference in Geneva, A Report Back to the Community." The
event lasts from 1 p.m. to 6 p.m., with poster displays from
1-2, presentations from 2-5, and a reception from 5-6.
Audience questions are encouraged. This symposium is
sponsored in part by Abbott Laboratories.
Presentations will include immunology and virology, clinical
care and treatment, prevention and behavioral science, and
policy and ethics.
The meeting will take place in Cole Hall, 513 Parnassus
Street, San Francisco. Those using public transportation can
take the N Judah to the UCSF stop on Irving Avenue -- and can
then either walk up a steep hill, or take an elevator in the
UCSF building up several stories to the Parnassus level, then
cross Parnassus Street and turn right to find number 513.
ISSN # 1052-4207
Copyright 1998 by John S. James. Permission granted for noncommercial reproduction, provided that our address
and phone number are included if more than short quotations are used.
|
This article was provided by AIDS Treatment News.
|
|