Objective 2.1: Encourage men to take care of themselves
Except in a handful of countries, men have a lower life expectancy
at birth and higher death rates during adulthood than women.
Healthy lifestyles and timely medical intervention can prevent or
cure many of the health problems that men face. However, many
boys and men may see themselves as somehow invulnerable to
risks or illnesses, and postpone seeking health care.
Generally, adolescence and young adulthood are times of good
health. However, during these stages of their lives many young
men and women do require access to health care. Many young
women are treated for sexually transmitted infections, sometimes
as a consequence of sexual coercion or rape. Rather than sexually
transmitted infections, trauma due to traffic accidents or physical
violence at the hands of other men are more common among
young men. The above emotional and physical traumas among
young women and men often result from a 'masculine' desire to
prove oneself or take risks.
Most societies allot the role of breadwinner to men and confer
special privileges on both men and boys compared to women and
girls. However, manhood brings with it a mix of personal costs as
well as benefits -- costs which are reflected in men's mental and
physical health. In many societies, men are conditioned not to
express emotions, to maintain formal relationships with their
children, to use violence to resolve conflicts and maintain "honour",
and to work outside the home from an early age. In this context, it
is worth noting that suicide worldwide is one of the three leading
causes of death for adolescents, with three times as many boys as
girls killing themselves. In some developed countries, the risk is
tripled yet again among young gay men.
Men need to accept that their health is important, for their own
well-being as well as those who are dependent on them. This is
true for all men irrespective of HIV status. HIV infection is a heavy
burden to bear, mentally, physically and emotionally. But even in
the absence of antiretroviral therapy, an individual can, on
average, live for over nine years following HIV infection before
falling seriously ill and survive up to a year beyond that. The
bottom line is: men do have some control over their health and the
goal is to convince them of this.
Ideas for Actions
- Pay greater attention to boys' health as part of school health education programmes.
- Train health workers to better understand the special health needs of boys and men.
- Train health workers to pay greater attention to the mental health of men.
- Design easy-to-understand information, education, and communication (IEC) materials for boys and men focusing on their common concerns and health problems.
- Create pocket-sized cards entitled, "Know Your Responsibilities and Rights" that carry information for boys on one side and girls on the other and distribute to schoolchildren.
- Advocate for culture-specific research on social and economic factors in relation to 'masculinity'; to find out more about the pressures on men to behave in particular ways.
Objective 2.2: Encourage men to take more care of their partners and their families
In most societies, men are expected to provide for their female
partners and children. It is true that some men are abusive or fail to
provide for their families, while others provide merely financial
support. However, it is increasingly recognized that a man's self-worth
is enhanced, not compromised, by actively caring for his
partner's and children's well-being.
Men who have emotional and sexual bonds with other men can
also provide strong support for each other, although this is more
difficult in societies where such relationships are illegal or not
respected. It is to be noted that in many countries, the first AIDS
care associations were established by gay men to provide support
for each other.
While we obviously care more for those with whom we have strong
emotional bonds, care can also be extended to partners in casual
sex encounters or those with whom injecting needles are shared. If
we expect others not to infect us, we need to make efforts not to
infect others.
Men can take care of their partners and families in many ways:
they can protect them by not bringing HIV into the household -- by
not having sexual relations or sharing injecting equipment with
others, or by always using condoms outside of the relationship and
using only clean needles and syringes. Mother-to-child
transmission is by far the most common cause of HIV infection in
young children. In most cases, the mother acquired HIV from the
father of her child. Raising awareness of mother-to-child
transmission of HIV can play a major role in protecting men, their
partners and their future children.
And men can be actively involved in the raising of their children,
offering options to them on how to respond to sexual advances,
discussing love and relationships, and act as a positive role model
for their sons.
Men can provide support for partners and children who are ill -- by
ensuring a steady income whenever possible; by encouraging sick
partners to rest and taking on the tasks that they would otherwise
perform, such as fetching water or cooking meals; and by providing
their children with love and affection.
Men who have contracted HIV can plan for the future -- by leaving
savings or income from land or other sources to ensure the family's
well-being. In developing countries, most HIV-positive people are
already poor. This combined with social and cultural practices,
nearly always result in the assets of a family being used to cover
the costs of care in the last years of life or to substitute for lost
income. Even so, men should make whatever provisions possible.
Men, women,
HIV and
children
Having at least one child is very important to men and women
across the world. When one or more partners is HIV-positive, the
question of parenting becomes difficult, partly because of the
possibility of infecting the other partner if he or she is not already
infected. Even with antiretroviral intervention there is no guarantee
that the child will not be HIV-positive.
"My wife reacted so badly when I tried to remind her that a man
could be HIV-positive that I preferred not to talk about it. Since then
we've had relations with a condom. More and more she wants to
have a child, and I am afraid of what might follow." -- Thomas, 40
and HIV-positive.
"Before I knew I had the virus, I used to want four children, two of
each sex. Now I will be content with one child to mark my time on
this earth but although there is only a one in four chance of mother-to-
child transmission, I am afraid of passing the virus to a future
child and causing the infant to suffer." -- Marc, 21
"I tested positive five years ago. I have a partner who tested
negative. Since then our problem has been whether to have a child
or not." -- Etienne, age not given.
Source: Kouadio, H. N'G. In: Foreman, M. et al. AIDS and Men:
taking risks or taking responsibility? London, Panos/Zed, 1999.
|
Ideas for Actions
- Establish programmes that encourage young, unmarried men to understand their roles as future parents and prepare them to be involved in parenthood, promoting planned fatherhood as a masculine ideal.
- Provide for men-only sessions in family welfare / reproductive health / sexually transmitted infection clinics. Gain the support of local community leaders to encourage men to attend.
- Arrange counselling for couples who are considering having children and/or worried about their HIV-status.
- Educate men on their potential role in, and responsibility for, HIV transmission to their children prior to and during, their partner's pregnancy.
- Promote access to high-quality voluntary testing and counselling for men and women before and during pregnancy.
- Bring men together to talk about their concerns regarding care for their families and help them develop the skills to talk to -- and listen to -- their partners and children.
- Support organizations of people living with HIV/AIDS and other groups that can provide support for those infected as well as for those caring for HIV-positive people.
- Hold experience-sharing meetings where people with HIV talk with others about how they care for their families.
- Use "agony" columns in newspapers to answer questions from men wanting to become more involved in care for their families.
- Work with writers for radio and TV soap operas to integrate examples of caring men into their story lines.
- Encourage male celebrities and sportsmen to talk about their caring relationships with their partners and children.
- Use the Internet to promote men's involvement with their families by creating attractive sites that promote men's involvement with their families.
- Assist HIV-positive men or those affected by HIV to plan for the future care of their children.
- Help men and women with HIV to communicate their serostatus to their partners.
Making a difference
Jaconia who is HIV-positive is working laying the floor of his new
house. He is a truck driver and is married to Jabu. She was part of
a group of HIV-positive patients at Hlabisa hospital in Kwazulu,
Natal, South Africa, who came together as a support group. They
were all trained as AIDS educators and then made the brave
decision to reveal their HIV status to their community in order to
make their educational work more effective.
"When my wife told me she had this disease it felt like the end.
Then I thought about it and saw that it was not like that. I have
learnt to live with the disease and now have come to love my wife
more and more. It does happen that I have many girlfriends, but
now I use a condom. You can feel it so well. It's the same as flesh
to flesh. I don't know when the time will come when AIDS is going
to kill me. I feel under pressure and that's why I am building this
new home for my children. I want to finish it as I am losing weight
and getting weaker. I taught myself to play Zulu guitar when I was
younger and I've written songs about incgulazi to warn people
about the dangers. My fifteen year old son now plays bass with
me. I hope my songs will stay with him when I am gone.
Jaconia died on 9 June 2000 and was buried on the 16 June,
Liberation Day. His funeral was an AIDS education one.
Source: Positives Lives: Positive Responses to HIV. A photo-documentary.
Project director: Kevin Ryan. kevryansyd@msn.com
|
A first step in changing men's attitudes towards seeking health
care is educating young people as to its benefits.
Some people fear that educating young people about sex will
encourage promiscuity. However, evidence shows that good-quality
sex education can lower levels of sexual risk-taking and
delay first sex. Sex education is most effective when given before
young people begin their sexual lives. Well-planned sex education
can help reduce the risk of contracting sexually transmitted
infections, including HIV, and unwanted pregnancy.
While many boys and girls feel pressured to have sex, most are
poorly informed about sexuality and reproduction. Parents need to
talk more with their children about sex, sexuality and gender roles.
Boys need to be taught that responsible sexual behaviour is a
positive aspect of masculinity, and both boys and girls should be
offered the chance to acquire the life skills needed to refuse sex or
negotiate safer sex.
Apart from the family, there are other valuable sources of
information and support for boys and girls. Teachers can provide
information on pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections and
help young people acquire useful life skills. Schools too can foster
respect for all communities, equality between men and women and
promote human rights.
Peer education can be an effective way of enabling frank
discussions between people of similar age and backgrounds. Boys
and girls can be trained as educators to inform and influence the
behaviour of their peers.
Health care providers often require training to be able to discuss
sexual health, HIV and life skills with boys and girls. An open and
trusting relationship between doctors, nurses and young patients
can be the beginning of building life long trust and
communication -- the basis for medical care and support.
Men who are HIV-positive and are willing to speak openly about
this can be a powerful force for change. From public figures such
as Philly Lutaaya (a Ugandan singer), Freddie Mercury (a British
singer), Magic Johnson (an American basketball player), Mr.
Justice Edwin Cameron (a Judge of the High Court of South Africa)
and Rudy Galindo (an American national figure skating champion)
to unknown individuals living quietly but openly in towns and
villages, men with HIV can and do lead fulfilling and exemplary
lives.
Children and young people who do not attend school, who live on
the streets or work from a tender age can be particularly vulnerable
to HIV infection. Over a hundred million children, the majority of
whom are from developing countries, lack access to primary
education. They urgently need information on sexual health and
HIV/AIDS and the skills with which to protect themselves from
exploitation and abuse.
Decline in HIV infection
The decline in HIV rates in Uganda has been attributed to the
postponement of first sex by young people and to an increase in
condom use. From 1989 to 1995, pregnant women were tested for
HIV infection when they made their first visit to antenatal clinics in
the urban centres of Kampala and Jinja. Overall, there was a 40%
decline in the rates of HIV among the women surveyed. In
population-based behavioural studies, conducted in 1989 and 1995
in Kampala and Jinja, men and women reported a 40% and 30%
increase in experience of condom use, respectively. Behavioural
surveys also showed a two-year delay in the age at first sexual
intercourse of young people aged 15-24 and a 9% decrease in
'casual' sex in the past year in young men aged 15-24.
Source: Asiimwe-Okiror et al. (AIDS 1997, 11:1757-1763).
|
Ideas for Actions
- Train and support parents to talk to children about sex.
- Promote positive male role models in the youth media.
- Promote peer education, in a variety of settings, as a cost-effective and efficient means of education on sexual health and HIV education.
- Train boys and men as peer educators in life skills, sexual health, and AIDS education.
- Integrate life skills, sexual health and HIV/AIDS education into all curricula from primary school to tertiary education. Develop such programmes in consultation with parents, teachers and students.
- Ask people living with HIV/AIDS to talk to young people in schools and in community forums about their experiences of life before and after their HIV diagnosis.
- Train community workers to use techniques such as games and role-plays to teach young people about life skills, sexual health, and HIV/AIDS.
Important life skills in the HIV/AIDS era
- Making sound decisions about relationships, sexual intercourse and drug use and standing by these decisions.
- Recognizing situations that seem likely to turn risky or violent.
- Knowing where, when and how to ask for help and support.
- Learning to negotiate for protected sex or other forms of safer sex.
- Caring for people with AIDS in the family and the community.
|
Health statistics from many parts of world confirm that injuries
resulting from violence are among the chief causes of mortality and
morbidity among young men.
In addition to the violence that men perpetrate on each other, men
inflict violence on women, some of it sexual. 35 studies from a
variety of countries in Africa, Asia, Latin America, Europe and
North America found that one-quarter to more than half of the
women reported having been physically abused by a present or
former partner. Sexually aggressive young men were themselves
more likely to have been sexually abused, to have witnessed
abuse of a family member, to have a sexually transmitted infection,
and to have used drugs or alcohol.
Sexual violence may take place in relationships. A recent study in
Northern India found that 46% of men reported abusing their wives,
and that these men were more likely to engage in extramarital sex
and have a sexually transmitted infection than non-abusive men.
Violence may also take place during dating. Studies among high
school and college students in New Zealand and the United States.
found that between 20 and 59 % of males and females said they
had experienced physical aggression during a dating relationship.
While nearly equal numbers of males and females reported that
they had been subjected to violence, male violence against women
tended to be more severe, and men tended to initiate this violence.
There are many difficulties in documenting sexual assault and
violence by boys and men. People subjected to sexual violence are
often afraid to report violations. Societal norms may portray sexual
coercion as part of boys' normal sexual behaviour. For example, a
widely publicized event in Kenya in 1991 in which 71 young women
were raped and 19 died in a group attack from their male
classmates, reportedly elicited the comment "boys will be boys".
Male violence drives the HIV epidemic in a number of ways. Rape
and sexual abuse may place women and children at risk of
contracting HIV. Sexual violence and mass migration are often the
results of war, and not only are families split up, and husbands and
wives separated, but in refugee camps and elsewhere women may
become the subject of unwanted demands for sex, or may have to
trade sex in order to survive. Innumerable instances of rape by
members of the armed forces and paramilitary groups have been
documented, and there is strong evidence that sexual violence, or
the threat of it, is used as a means of terrorizing or subjugating
both women and other men.
In addition to the possibility of HIV infection through sexual
violence, other health consequences include physical injury,
sexually transmitted infections and unwanted pregnancy. Some
studies have shown that men and women who had been raped or
forced to have sex during their childhood or adolescence were
twice as likely to have multiple partners in a single year and to
engage in casual sex. They were also four times as likely to be sex
workers, and women who had been subjected to childhood sexual
violence were twice as likely to be heavy consumers of alcohol and
nearly three times as likely to become pregnant before the age of
18.
Young men are more frequently studied as perpetrators rather than
as subjects of violence. However, some research shows that
young men are also subjected to violence. And when they are
allowed to do so, young men express their fear of the potential for
violence within themselves, the threat of violence from other men
and of the violence inflicted on them.
Ideas for Actions
- Develop programmes that offer young men constructive ways of resolving conflicts, developing their identities and expressing their emotions.
- Develop programmes that discuss violence within relationships or during dating.
- Highlight sexual violence as a cause of HIV transmission.
- Highlight the link between sexual violence and the future behaviour of people subjected to violence and their increased risk of HIV infection.
- Offer opportunities to discuss the violence boys witness and to reduce the stress and consequences associated with being a subject of violence.
- Establish programmes in settings where violent and delinquent behaviour by boys is prevalent and sensitize boys from an early age.
- Find ways of engaging young men positively in their community, family and peer groups.
- Educate parents, teachers, health personnel and other youth-serving professionals about the origins of violent behaviour among boys, helping them to effectively tackle the boys rather than responding in punitive ways.
Reducing violence
In response to men's violence against women, including violence
by young men against young women, some people have begun to
ask: What are we doing directly with men, including young men, to
prevent them from being violent to women? Many industrialized
countries have long used court-mandated therapy for men,
including adolescents, accused or convicted of domestic violence
or sexual assault. In North America, Australia, Western Europe,
and to a limited extent in some parts of Latin America, there are
groups working on date rape awareness and domestic or courtship
violence. Some of these group activities have taken place with
military recruits, in sports locker rooms and in schools with the goal
of increasing men's awareness about such issues, or with the idea
of creating positive peer pressure so that young men themselves
convince their male peers that such behaviour is unacceptable. In
a few countries in Latin America, NGOs have started voluntary
discussion groups with men, including young men, who would like
to work in a group setting to discuss their past acts of violence
against women and their desire to prevent such acts in the future.
Source: What About Boys? A Literature Review on the Health and
Development of Adolescent Boys, WHO, CAH, FCH/CAH/00.7,
2000.
|
A number of settings present boys and men with a higher than
average risk of contracting HIV. These include:
- Men in prisons may contract HIV through shared injecting equipment, consensual or forced sex with other prisoners or staff (usually male) or with visitors from outside (usually female).
- Men in the military, who may have sex with a relatively small group of women -- a situation which encourages rapid transmission of HIV -- and/or who may have sex with other men may contract HIV. There have been reports from some countries of high rates of HIV infection among military forces.
- Sailors and fishermen who spend weeks or months at sea with sex workers popularly known as "hostesses".
- Men and boys who sell sex or exchange sex for food or shelter. Male sex workers
- Homeless boys who have sex with other street children or who exchange sex for a meal, a bed or some emotional comfort, no matter how transient.
- Mostly underage boys who drop out of school because of poverty and are often employed in jobs where the working conditions are harsh.
- Migrants who have sex with men or women as a means of alleviating loneliness and stress.
- Boys in care institutions or boarding schools who have forced or consensual sex with other boys or staff members.
Special settings offer special challenges that require suitable
responses. For example, those in charge of such settings, e.g.
military leaders, governors of prisoner, boat owners, etc., are often
resistant to the idea of change. In situations where forced sex is
common, it is practically impossible to institute safer sex.
Nonetheless, persistence can pay dividends; innovative HIV
prevention programmes are now in place in the Zambian armed
forces, prisons in Ukraine and for male sex workers in Morocco,
Costa Rica and Brazil.
Ideas for Actions
- Use the success stories about prison-based HIV interventions to explain to prison warders, administrators and the government that the provision of sterile injecting equipment and condoms have not posed a threat to the safety of prison warders.
- Initiate debate on the human rights of prisoners (i.e. recognizing that people are in jail for a crime and their incarceration should not jeopardize their rights to health, security of the person, equality before the law and freedom from inhuman and degrading treatment).
- Promote debate on the need for HIV prevention programmes in prison that are rooted in the realities of prison life.
- Facilitate interventions approved by prison administrators and government and run by community organizations inside prisons. These should be sensitive to the specific needs of prisoners and their sexual and drug-injecting partners both within and outside of prison. Promote safer sex and ration out sterile injecting equipment and condoms to inmates or provide them in places where people can pick them up in private.
- Provide treatment for sexually transmitted infections for prisoners alongside counselling and voluntary testing services, and regular encouragement to use the services.
- Explain safer sex and provide sterile injecting equipment and condoms to boys in institutional care either as a ration, or in places where people can pick them up in private.
- Provide treatment for sexually transmitted infections for boys in institutional care, alongside counselling and voluntary testing services with regular encouragement to use the services.
- Request high-ranking military officers to take charge of implementing HIV prevention programmes which address the specific risks faced by members of the armed forces, such as sex with sex workers, rape and sex between men.
- Promote condom distribution among soldiers as well as voluntary and confidential counselling and testing for HIV. For example, the United Nations recently decided to issue all its peacekeeping personnel with one condom per day.
- Undertake peer education in workplaces where young boys may frequently be found, such as motorcycle stands, construction sites, gas stations, etc.
- Translate HIV prevention material into the languages used by migrants and ethnic minorities, and distribute it to migrant organizations, health service providers, NGOs, lawyers and others who come into contact with illegal migrants.
- Promote outreach and peer education programmes for immigrants and ethnic minority communities.
- Institute or support already existing programmes or organizations which work with migrants, itinerant workers, male sex workers and the homeless to include HIV prevention, care and support within their work.
- Provide HIV-related information, health services and prevention materials to boys in boarding schools, alongside the opportunity to talk about sex, sexuality and drug use.
Ukraine
turn-around
In 1995-96, in Ukraine, the HIV epidemic was causing disruption in
the management and allocation of prisoners, including
unacceptable and expensive compulsory testing and isolation of
inmates. The situation was characterized by high levels of fear
amongst staff and prisoners. Towards the end of 1996 the situation
began to change in response to the dramatic rise in the numbers of
prisoners with HIV. A programme of HIV prevention in Ukraine's
penitentiary establishments was approved by the minister of the
interior and new guidelines were issued on HIV prevention in
prisons, with a change in the legal policy framework.
In 1997, with support from UNAIDS, the Ministry of the Interior, the
prison medical services, and the National AIDS Committee
launched a series of workshops for senior prison authorities, staff
and inmates. The workshops were successful in informing
participants about HIV, altering attitudes towards HIV infection and
in devising local plans for prevention of HIV infection in prisons.
These were subsequently developed into a national prison service
plan and approved by the director general of the prison service.
The key elements of the model developed and adopted by Ukraine
are: enlisting high-level management support, education for
prevention, access to the condoms and disinfectants, a
multidisciplinary approach and an ethical procedure for voluntary
HIV testing.
Source: Best Practice Case Study: Joint Project of the Ministry of
the Interior and UNAIDS for the Reduction of HIV and AIDS in the
Prison System of the Ukraine (forthcoming).
|
Reaching truck drivers
Every day, 2000 trucks are ferried across the Jamuma
(Brahmaputra) river at Aricha Ghat in Bangladesh. Drivers and
their trucks wait for hours, sometimes days, for their turn. While
they are waiting, they may visit a sex worker or first they can go to
the recreation centre established by CEDAR (Concern for
Environmental Development and Research). The centre provides
truckers with clean bathrooms and recreational facilities, including
games, radio and television. The centre also shows films on
sexually transmitted infections, including HIV, offers free medical
check-ups and free medicines, and condoms are available both in
the toilets and on demand.
Adapted from Majumder, M.K. In: Foreman, M. et al. AIDS and
Men: taking risks or taking responsibility? London, Panos/Zed,
1999.
|
This article was provided by
UNAIDS.
It is a part of the publication Objectives and Ideas for Action, 2000 World AIDS Campaign.