Hateful Words From DC Writer Keep Stigma and Ignorance Going
By Candace Y.A. Montague
May 3, 2011
Last week, Washington Examiner columnist Gregory Kane, wrote an op-ed about the savage beating of a transgender woman named Chrissy Polis in a Baltimore McDonald's. The article stated that the victim "has been repeatedly referred to in news stories as a "woman." Not because he was born a woman, and not because he has two x chromosomes that women have, but merely because he thinks he is." Kane also stated "Because Polis is transgendered, he's entitled to extra protection, according to the "hate crimes" police. Had Polis, who's white, been just an actual white woman taking a beat-down because of the color of her skin, not her sexuality, we wouldn't have heard word one from anybody about filing "hate crimes" charges against Polis' assailants." Using incorrect pronouns and down-playing the crime as just a simple assault is part of what keeps stigma alive and well in our community.
Let's set the record straight. A person's sex is something that is assigned to them at birth. A person's gender is the sex they identify with the most. Ms. Polis is a transgender female, assigned as a male at birth but she obviously identifies herself as a female. Referring to her with the wrong pronouns is outright disrespectful. It creates the same kind of inflammation as a white man calling a black man 'boy' does. It also sends an ugly message to people who witness such flippancy: I see what you are but I'm going to call you what I want.
People with HIV are judged similarly as transgender people. The judgment is "you're getting what you deserve." Mr. Kane minimizes the severity of the beating and questions whether it's a hate crime or not. His words almost lead the reader to think that Polis should be ashamed of herself. This is tantamount to the belief that having HIV is nothing special and it is something to be ashamed of. Well, being transgender is special in part because it carries a unique set of prejudices and stigma just as having HIV carries a unique set of prejudices and stigma. In both cases, the person is often outcasted and preyed upon out of fear. In both cases, people are fighting against something they simply don't understand. Either way, no human being deserves to be discriminated against (beaten, bullied, or humiliated) because of who they are or what disease they have.
Kill the stigma with education. Learn more about transgender people by clicking here. Locally, you can consult with Transgender Health Empowerment or Sexual Minority Youth Assistance League (SMYAL) for answers to your questions about transgender people.
Feel free to post your comments below.
D.C. HIV/AIDS Examiner
Candace Y.A. Montague
Candace Y.A. Montague has been learning about HIV since 1988 (and she has the certificates from the American Red Cross to prove it). Health is a high priority to Candace because she believes that nothing can come of your life if you're not healthy enough to enjoy it. One of her two master's degrees is in Community Health Promotion and Education. Candace was inspired to act against HIV after seeing a documentary in 2008 about African-American women and HIV. She knew that writing was the best way for her to make a difference and help inform others. Candace is a native Washingtonian and covers HIV news all around D.C. She has covered fundraisers, motorcycle rides, town hall meetings, house balls, Capitol Hill press conferences, election campaigns and protests for The DC Examiner.com and emPower News Magazine.
Subscribe to Candace's Blog:
November 25, 2013 - Magic Johnson and Friends Discuss Life and HIV: A Blog Entry by Candace Y.A. Montague
November 5, 2013 - How People With HIV Can Use the Affordable Care Act Website
June 3, 2013 - Michael Douglas, HPV, and Throat Cancer: A Blog Entry by Candace Y.A. Montague
April 5, 2013 - The Sexual Health Lessons of Tyler Perry's Tempation: A Blog Entry by Candace Y.A. Montague
March 25, 2013 - Candace's AIDS News Update: A Blog Entry by Candace Y.A. Montague
A Brief Disclaimer:
The opinions expressed by TheBody.com's bloggers are entirely their own, and do not necessarily reflect the views of TheBody.com itself.