Developed Nations Receive Poor Grades on Report Card Assessing Response to HIV/AIDS
December 1, 2008
Although wealthy countries might be better equipped to provide antiretroviral treatment to HIV-positive people than some developing nations, wealthy nations often are less effective at collecting the data necessary to understand and curb HIV/AIDS, according to a study released last week by AIDS Accountability International, the Financial Times reports. In this first attempt to assess countries' compliance with commitments they made at the United Nations in 2001 and 2006 to ramp up their response to HIV/AIDS, the score card highlights that many high-income nations -- including most European countries and the U.S. -- are "worse at monitoring and/or reporting on the fundamentals of their epidemics and their responses" than their low-income counterparts. In addition, AAI found that although developed countries insisted on monitoring and reporting when they provided funding for antiretroviral treatment in the developing world, they failed to meet the same standards at home (Jack, Financial Times, 11/25).
According to the Times, AAI said that the current data made available are inadequate to assess international progress, and it called for auditing to ensure that data provided by national governments on their HIV/AIDS policies are independently validated. AAI also said that the existing 25 indicators recommended by the United Nations are "necessary but insufficient" because they fail to monitor issues such as the quality of implementation of policy. This creates "major obstacles to holding governments accountable," according to the report (Financial Times, 11/25).
Chinese Health Officials, UNAIDS Pledge to Fight HIV-Associated Stigma, Discrimination; Reduce Spread of HIV Among Migrant Workers
This article was provided by Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. It is a part of the publication Kaiser Daily HIV/AIDS Report. Visit the Kaiser Family Foundation's website to find out more about their activities, publications and services.