Needle Exchange Questions and Answers
September 10, 2008
At a needle exchange program, injection drug users bring their used equipment to a known exchange site and trade their dirty syringes for clean equipment. Syringes are dispensed on a one-for-one basis. Used syringes are disposed of in accordance with established biohazardous waste standards. Needle exchange programs are intended to prevent the spread of the HIV virus and other blood-borne diseases, such as hepatitis B and C, among injection drug users and, therefore, their sexual partners and children. Equally important as the actual exchange of syringes is the opportunity for outreach workers to provide participants with updated information and referrals regarding medical and social services in the community related to both drug treatment and HIV medical care and support services.
Yes. Scientific study after scientific study has shown that needle exchange reduces the number of new HIV infections. Studies show that needle exchange programs can reduce HIV infections by at least one-third and reduce risk behavior by as much as 80%.
No. Scientific study after scientific study has shown that needle exchange does not increase drug use when conducted with referrals to both drug treatment and HIV medical care and support services.
No. Needle exchange programs actually encourage individuals to bring back dirty needles to trade them in at the needle exchange site. In fact, the discarding of used, infectious needles on the streets was virtually eliminated due to needle exchange in New Haven, according to a US Conference of Mayors report. Eliminating needles on the streets can reduce the risk of accidental needle sticks to children and others. Law enforcement officials report that "pat downs" of those individuals participating in a needle exchange program are less likely to result in needle sticks because syringes are more likely to be capped.
The CDC reports that more than 33% of all AIDS cases are among injection drug users, their partners and children, and the numbers continue to climb. Over 63% of AIDS cases among women are related to injection drug use and over 50% of AIDS cases among children are attributable to injection drug use by their parents, according to the CDC. Because AIDS cases are growing fastest among these vulnerable populations, needle exchange should be an option for local communities to utilize as part of a comprehensive HIV prevention plan. In San Francisco, needle exchange, coupled with effective prenatal HIV intervention, has been credited with eliminating pediatric AIDS for the past two years. Results like this show that needle exchange can directly reduce HIV infection among drug users, their partners and children.
Yes. Two recent national surveys indicate that a majority of voters support needle exchange, and a Kaiser Family Foundation survey in March 1996 found that 66% of Americans support such programs. At least 100 needle exchange programs, in both fixed and mobile sites, currently operate in the United States. Local communities have developed and implemented needle exchange programs, which operate in a manner appropriate to the community standards and norms of the locale.
At this time, there are three separate and distinct prohibitions on needle exchange programs at the federal level -- in the Ryan White CARE Act authorization; in the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) authorization; and in the FY 1997 Labor-Health and Human Services (HHS)-Education appropriations legislation. The prohibition in the Labor-HHS appropriations legislation not only applies to the Ryan White and SAMHSA authorizations, but also to HIV prevention funding at the CDC. The Labor-HHS appropriations legislation prohibits needle exchange "unless the Secretary of Health and Human Services determines that such programs are effective in preventing the spread of HIV and do not encourage the use of illegal drugs."
The Secretary of Health and Human Services, in recognition of the overwhelming scientific evidence that needle exchange is effective in preventing the spread of HIV and does not increase the use of illegal drugs, should exercise the waiver authority provided under the FY 1997 Labor HHS appropriations legislation. Once the federal prohibition is removed, resources should be made available, if desired, so that state and local public health officials may utilize appropriate federal resources for needle exchange as part of a community's comprehensive HIV prevention plan.
This article was provided by San Francisco AIDS Foundation. Visit San Francisco AIDS Foundation's Web site to find out more about their activities, publications and services.