April 21, 2000
Jeff Getty of ACT UP Golden Gate told San Francisco Frontiers (April 6, 2000), "The name ACT UP has been destroyed in this town . . . we will continue along the old lines . . . but we will have one new focus: a national teleconferencing system with an 800 number so that cities with only one sharp activist can connect to the rest of us."
ACT UP San Francisco -- which tells people not to be tested or treated for HIV infection, and which opposes AIDS clinical trials ("AIDS research isn't medicine -- it's murder") -- has disrupted treatment meetings in San Francisco for years; activists and medical professionals alike have been concerned for their personal safety. (For a report on this week's disruption, see "More Violence from ACT UP/SF: Woman Injured at HIV Treatment Forum," in the Bay Area Reporter, April 20, 2000, page 1.)
Elsewhere, ACT UP San Francisco's best known action was to invade a medical meeting at the World AIDS Conference in Vancouver, Canada, in July 1996, and throw red liquid on the speakers, in front of an audience of more than a thousand physicians and researchers. ACT UP San Francisco is also expected to have a high profile at the World AIDS Conference in Durban, South Africa, July 9-14, 2000; it has already won sympathy in South Africa when the conference organizers canceled its booth A1A (apparently it had reserved one of the most prominent exhibit booths in the conference facility, although some legitimate activist organizations were turned down for booths), after learning about the nature of the organization.
The ACT UP Golden Gate / Survive AIDS letter to the community lists other accomplishments:
But ACT UP/Golden Gate has not always succeeded in informing the public about what it has accomplished. (One example: When we checked our email to find the ACT UP Golden Gate letter to the community which contains the accomplishments quoted above, the only copy we found had been distributed by ACT UP San Francisco, under the introductory message, "After ten years of pushing poisons onto gay men, ACT UP Golden Gate is DEAD! Long live ACT UP SF! AIDS is over!")
Part of the continuing public confusion of the organizations may stem from the fact that ACT UP San Francisco has a budget about 20 times larger than that of ACT UP Golden Gate -- about $1,666,000 in its last fiscal year, mostly from sale of medical marijuana, vs. $83,000 for ACT UP Golden Gate, according to a widely-quoted article in the Bay Area Reporter, a San Francisco gay newspaper, on March 23. For example, on the night before the first Survive AIDS meeting, dozens of 4 1/4 by 5 1/2 inch flyers reading "www.surviveaids.com" were pasted onto news racks, advertising signs, windows, light poles, and parking meters in San Francisco's Castro district; shortly after midnight, this writer counted 70 of them pasted in a single block. There were six different headlines (THE AIDS LIE IS ANTI-GAY!, BAN THE HIV TEST!, AIDS RESEARCH KILLS QUEERS!, HIV IS HOMOPHOBIA!, TUNE OUT TERROR!, and FLUSH YOUR AIDS DRUGS!); each flyers contained only a headline and the Web address. Survive AIDS had registered www.surviveaids.org -- but others had registered www.surviveaids.com and www.surviveaids.net, which pointed to a page on the ACT UP San Francisco Web site. Survive AIDS did not have the resources to routinely register all three, while ACT UP San Francisco could afford to register and publicize names other than its own.
This writer did not support the name change, fearing worldwide consequences if the name ACT UP is abandoned, since it is the best-known AIDS activist name in the world; it could then be used more freely to deliver a very different message. But in San Francisco the change had to be made, because the people doing the work want to help themselves and others survive the epidemic -- not to keep fighting public confusion when ACT UP San Francisco is intensely unpopular, and even AIDS professionals still sometimes confused the two groups.
ISSN # 1052-4207
Copyright 2000 by John S. James. Permission granted for noncommercial reproduction, provided that our address and phone number are included if more than short quotations are used.
Back to the AIDS Treatment News April 21, 2000 contents page.