The total numbers of cases reported to the Viral Hepatitis Surveillance Program (VHSP) are shown in Table 1A. Approximately 36% of hepatitis A cases, 26% of hepatitis B cases, and 18% of NANB hepatitis cases reported to the NNDSS in 1993 were also reported to the VHSP. These percentages reflect a substantial decline in reporting to the VHSP. Reporting to the VHSP remains inconsistent among states, with increasing numbers of states reporting fewer of their NNDSS cases to the VHSP than in previous years (Table 1B). In 1987, six states reported to VHSP less than 15% of their NNDSS cases; in 1993, this trend increased to 12 states.
Table 1A. Cases Reported to Viral Hepatitis Surveillance Program Compared with NNDSS, by Type of Submission, 1991-93
Year
1991
1992
1993
Reports submitted on Form CDC 53.1 Rev. 8-89 (new form)
18,064
16,433
13,563
Reports submitted on Form CDC 53.1 Rev. 8-84 (old form)
1,772
884
617
Reports submitted electronically as extended NETSS* records
810
961
1,427
Total case reports submitted to VHSP
20,646
18,278
15,607
Total cases serologically confirmed
19,014
16,916
14,469
Total cases meeting case definition for acute hepatitis
17,094
15,362
13,199
Symptomatic hepatitis A
9,621
9,735
8,643
Symptomatic hepatitis B
5,771
4,411
3,526
Hepatitis A and B co-infection
237
151
174
Symptomatic non-A, non-B hepatitis
1,465
1,065
856
Total cases reported to NNDSS
47,223
46,132
43,012
Hepatitis A
24,378
23,112
24,238
Hepatitis B
18,003
16,126
13,361
Hepatitis non-A, non-B
3,582
6,010
4,786
Hepatitis, unspecified
1,260
884
627
* National Electronic Telecommunications System for Surveillance National Notifiable Diseases Surveillance System
Table 1B. Proportion of NNDSS-Reported Cases Reported to VHSP by States, 1993
75%-100%
50%-74%
25%-49%
15%-24%
0%-14%
Alabama
Colorado
New York (excl. NYC)
Arizona
Alaska
District of Columbia
Indiana
Rhode Island
Georgia
Arkansas
Delaware
Maine
Wyoming
California
Florida
Massachusetts
Connecticut
Hawaii
Michigan
Idaho
Iowa
Missouri
Kansas
Illinois
New Hampshire
Kentucky
Iowa
Virginia
Mississippi
Louisiana
Washington
Montana
Maryland
Wisconsin
New Jersey
Minnesota
New Mexico
North Carolina
New York City
North Dakota
Oregon
Nebraska
South Carolina
Nevada
South Dakota
Ohio
Tennessee
Oklahoma
Texas
Pennsylvania
Utah
Vermont
West Virginia
The agreement between reporting to the NNDSS and to the VHSP does not necessarily measure the completeness of reporting from a particular state, since not all cases may be reported to the NNDSS and the two systems have different reporting criteria. The increasing discrepancy between the two systems has resulted in differences in the relative proportions of types of viral hepatitis reported. Before 1990, the proportions of reported cases by type were similar between the two surveillance systems. Since then, the proportion of hepatitis cases reported as hepatitis A to the two systems have remained similar, but the proportion of cases reported as hepatitis B have been discrepant: 24% to 27% of the total VHSP cases were reported as hepatitis B, compared with 35% to 38% of total cases reported to NNDSS. The VHSP also received reports on smaller proportions of the total number of NANB hepatitis cases (7% to 8% of total cases) than did NNDSS (up to 13% of total cases).
Advertisement
These differences in proportions of cases are partly due to the fact that VHSP excludes cases that do not meet the case definition (VHSP eliminated 15% of reported cases as non-cases in 1993). In addition, because of strict adherence to the case definition, VHSP classified a larger proportion of reported cases as nonspecific hepatitis: 15% of cases were classified as hepatitis unspecified by the VHSP during 1993 compared with 1.5% of cases reported to NNDSS. Beginning with data collected in 1995, hepatitis cases that have type unspecified are no longer requested or printed in the MMWR.
The VHSP excludes reported cases that do not meet the case definition for acute viral hepatitis (see "Case Definition" section), including cases that seem to be due to chronic infections. Some responses to the VHSP questionnaires are incomplete, and the information is insufficient to verify the case as an acute infection, or to confirm the serologic type of hepatitis, even though partial testing may have been done. Cases may also be reported too late to be included in the analysis. The latest date for submitting case reports to the VHSP for the calendar year is March 31 of the following year.