India's Voiceless Women Are Easy Prey for AIDS

"The $100 million that Bill Gates' philanthropy will add to the battle against HIV and AIDS in India is a welcome expression of concern for what Gates rightly portrays as one of the worst epidemics in the world. But the Gates Foundation's generous support may be undone by factors that neither the government of India nor its donors are addressing: the voicelessness of women and increasing violence against those most affected by the epidemic. ...

"The long-standing insubordination of women and girls in Indian society takes on lethal dimensions with the rapid spread of HIV. Though men can experiment with sex outside of marriage without any social stigma, women do not even have the status to demand that husbands who may bring sexually transmitted diseases home use condoms. ...

"...Prostitutes are continually subjected to violence by police officers, who take their cue from society's condemnation of these women. ...The violence of AIDS-related stigma also confronts AIDS educators, homosexual men and other marginalized people.

"The most effective education on HIV transmission is done by those trusted by the community at risk. This means that sex workers have the best chance of helping other sex workers protect themselves from HIV. But... the police apparently do not recognize the lifesaving work done by AIDS educators, and these people face consistent abuse.

"Finally, the Indian government and its well-meaning donors seem to think that HIV prevention alone can succeed, ignoring the needs of millions already living with HIV and AIDS. These people continue to face abuse and discrimination in the health care system, and unless they are rich they can hardly hope for the basics of treatment of even secondary infections, let alone medicines for HIV itself.

"India is one of the biggest producers of the drugs that have transformed the lives of people with AIDS in wealthy countries, yet millions of Indians cannot get these medicines.

"The Gates Foundation can do India and its own investment a favor by insisting that the money be used to help the voiceless women with HIV and AIDS."

Seshu is founder and general secretary of Sangram, which works with sex workers and rural women in Sangli, India. She has been named a Human Rights Defender by Human Rights Watch. Csete is director of the HIV/AIDS and human rights program of Human Rights Watch.

Back to other CDC news for December 16, 2002

Previous Updates