Open Letter From ATAC to Abbott's CEO, Miles White
Dear Mr. White:
A recent action by your company has shaken the HIV/AIDS community to its very core, threatening to transform and erode a productive relationship that has evolved between us in combatting this epidemic. The AIDS Treatment Activists Coalition (ATAC) is a national coalition of AIDS activists, many living with HIV/AIDS, working together to end the AIDS epidemic by advancing research on HIV/AIDS. We recently became aware of a price increase of greater than 400% for Abbott's protease inhibitor ritonavir (Norvir). This price increase may well have been the result of overly eager marketing and sales personnel seeing and seizing an opportunity without considering the absolutely appalling effects this move would have on public perception and community/consumer relations.
As you know, Norvir was granted accelerated approval by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, based on its encouraging performance in clinical trials evaluating its effects on both surrogate and clinical markers. When used at the approved therapeutic dose (600 mg BID), it is associated with significant toxicities and side effects that render it intolerable for many HIV-positive individuals. However, the drug has enjoyed continued and growing use, albeit at smaller doses, as a pharmacokinetic (PK) booster for other, more tolerable protease inhibitors by inhibiting the CYP3A4 hepatic enzymes, which metabolize other drugs. In fact, Norvir-boosted protease inhibitor therapy has created a novel therapeutic approach for achieving more potent antiretroviral efficacy, especially in patients with fewer treatment options, such as "salvage" therapy patients who harbor resistance to several or many HIV drugs. Consider the example of an investigational protease inhibitor, tipranavir, being developed by Boehringer Ingelheim, which has activity against resistant virus but which will also require boosting with up to 400 mg of Norvir.
Surprisingly, the price of another Abbott drug, Kaletra (itself a Norvir-boosted protease inhibitor) has stayed the same, providing an unquestionable economic advantage to choosing Kaletra over other boosted protease inhibitor regimens (such as the recently approved drugs Reyataz and Lexiva), which may now as much as double in price. The price of boosted tipranavir, if approved, could now be around the price of Fuzeon, the most expensive antiretroviral drug ever developed (around $20,000/year). Does this seem like a rational direction for protease inhibitor-based therapy?
Instead of being grateful that Norvir still has therapeutic application and will enjoy continued sales, Abbott has apparently made an ultimatum that salvage patients who need new therapeutic options, or even those who just need more potent therapy (arguably any patient with HIV), will pay, and pay dearly. Unless, of course, doctors and patients choose Kaletra, which, as mentioned above, has not increased in price and will be cheaper than other boosted options.
Unfortunately, one drug regimen does not fit all, and many patients can benefit virologically or metabolically from drugs other than Kaletra.
We appreciate the need to remain profitable, especially in uncertain economic times, but this price increase goes far beyond what is reasonable or necessary. No amount of research and development justifies this type of increase for this type of drug, especially when research to improve Norvir will also extend its patent life. We understand Abbott's preemptive move to ease restrictions on its Patient Assistance Program for Norvir. We know that prices for AIDS Drug Assistance Programs (ADAP) will not be affected until renegotiation in 2005. However, we cannot accept this unprecedented opportunism in the face of dwindling resources and growing numbers of HIV infections.
What Abbott has done will negatively affect healthcare resource allocations (public and private), drug research and development, and patient care and well-being for decades to come.
Abbott has just changed the landscape of HIV/AIDS for the worse. Is this what it wants to be known for? ATAC urges Abbott to reconsider its recent actions and to rejoin the battle against HIV/AIDS by advancing research and therapeutics until this scourge against humanity is conquered. Further, we challenge you to roll back the price of Norvir. Abbott has obviously regained its development costs many times over with this drug, which received full approval on the basis of a minimal development package and without an Expanded Access Program.
We believe that it is in the overall best interest of your company to reconsider this shameful and destructive path. We look forward to learning that you have reversed this inhumane decision as soon as possible.
Very truly yours,
Lynda Dee & Matt Sharp, Co-Chairs
Call Miles White and tell him what you think: (847) 937-6100
This article was provided by Gay Men's Health Crisis. It is a part of the publication GMHC Treatment Issues. Visit GMHC's website to find out more about their activities, publications and services.