HIV Criminalization Update: Some U.S. Nondisclosure Laws Advance, While Others Recede
September 22, 2017
And finally, the hopeful:
Ohio law requires a person living with HIV to disclose their status before having sex or else risk charges of felonious assault and up to eight years in prison. But that might change as the state Supreme Court considers arguments it heard in May that the law violates free speech rights by focusing only on disclosure and not actual transmission.
The plaintiff, Orlando Batista, was convicted of not disclosing his HIV status to his girlfriend before the two had sex. His girlfriend later tested HIV positive and Batista was arrested. He pled no contest and admitted to transmitting HIV to at least two other women. He was sentenced to eight years in prison.
The state Supreme Court decision will affect not only Batista but also potentially tens of thousands of Ohioans. As of 2015, more than 22,300 people in Ohio were living with HIV.
In Canada, a person living with HIV who has sex without a condom and does not have a low viral load must disclose their status to a sexual partner. If they don't, they risk charges of aggravated sexual assault and imprisonment.
Canada's criminal code contains no laws specific to HIV nondisclosure; instead, charges of aggravated sexual assault are filed in cases of nondisclosure.
According to the Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, at least 184 people in 200 cases have been charged since 1989. In 2012, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that a person must disclose if there is a "realistic possibility of transmission." The vague wording and lack of official prosecutorial guidelines in Ontario have left prosecutors to their own devices when deciding how to approach HIV cases, or whether to even prosecute. Since 2012, at least nine cases have been taken to court in Ontario, according to the Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network.
What Ontario prosecutors do have is a 72-page document on how to secure a conviction, including what kinds of information should be sought from public health officials. In other words, health records can be used against a defendant, which undoubtedly discourages people from seeking medical care.
Federal Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould has called it an "over-criminalization of HIV nondisclosure" and is looking at introducing changes.
Between 2014 and 2016, the People Living with HIV Stigma Index surveyed 70 people in Michigan.
Among its findings, the index found that "a significant number of the respondents to our questionnaire didn't trust Michigan courts to give them a fair trial, if they were accused of nondisclosure. They cited the, 'New Jim Crow' which often leads to discretionary adjudication, causing disparities along racial lines, and dissuades many of those at risk from getting tested, because, what they don't know won't hurt them."
Nearly half (46%) believed it is reasonable for a person with HIV to not disclose to a sexual partner for fear of prosecution. Given the disproportionate criminalization of black people, 67% of black respondents compared with 9% of white respondents believed that nondisclosure for fear of prosecution is reasonable. Furthermore, people who had previously been detained (62%) were more likely than those who had never been detained (42%) to agree.
The survey also asked, "If someone were to file charges against you claiming that you were a sexual partner and you did not disclose your HIV status to him or her, do you trust that you would be given a fair hearing in Michigan's criminal justice system?" Interestingly, nearly 60% of respondents, regardless of race, said no.
Finally, 51% of the people surveyed believed it was somewhat (33%) or very reasonable (18%) to delay care for fear of being prosecuted for nondisclosure. In other words, HIV criminalization deters people from testing and seeking care.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)'s most recent data (from 2014), an estimated 1.1 million people are living with HIV in the United States. Eighty-five percent have been diagnosed and know that they have HIV. Nearly half (49%) are living with a suppressed viral load, meaning that they not only are able to live longer, healthier lives, but they have a dramatically reduced risk for spreading HIV to others.
The CDC says that nine out of ten HIV transmissions are spread by people who have not been diagnosed or are not in care. Therefore, "[r]educing the number of undiagnosed HIV infections and getting more people into care present the greatest opportunities to improve viral suppression in America."
However, as the People Living with HIV Stigma Index has noted, continuing -- and expanding --HIV criminalization works against this goal.
Victoria Law is a freelance writer and editor. Her work focuses on the intersections of incarceration, gender and resistance. She is the author of Resistance Behind Bars: The Struggles of Incarcerated Women. You can find more of her work at Victorialaw.net.
This article was provided by TheBody.
Add Your Comment:
(Please note: Your name and comment will be public, and may even show up in
Internet search results. Be careful when providing personal information! Before
adding your comment, please read TheBody.com's Comment Policy.)
The content on this page is free of advertiser influence and was produced by our editorial team. See our advertising policy.