RE:Is this ARS or something else...Please help...I want to donate (THANK YOU!)
Feb 3, 2011
As always, you were right Dr. Bob! I tested -ve at 100 days.Whooo Hooo and thank you!!
Although, I still have a few symptoms that remain undiagnosed after 3 months and repeat visits to ENTs & several internists. I have sore throat that has been waxing and waning for 3 months and ringing & pressure in the ears for the last 6 weeks. The ENT diagnosed GERD as the cause for the sore throat and prescribed Nexium. But it hasnt helped a lot as yet. All my other STD tests and infectious disease tests such as Mono, Lymes, & CMV were negative. Im not sure what alternate strategy should I follow other than wait and watch (Your advice will be much appreciated)...
For other readers, Id like to echo Dr. Bobs opinion that symptoms do not equal HIV. In my case, I had almost every symptom that one could associate with HIV over the last 3 months such as sore throat, mild fever, diarrhea & loose bowels, muscle weakness, dry sensitive skin, itchy red eyes, tinnitus, and rash under thighs (at 9.5 weeks), after a low-risk exposure.
I tested undetectable by PCR at days 17 and 35 and negative by antibody test at days 28, 51, 72, and 100.
I have made a $250 donation to your foundation, confirmation code ******D4434E, and I want to donate $250 to a HIV/AIDS organization in India (my home country) where medical assistance is extremely limited to the people in need, and general poverty make it unaffordable for many people to afford medications. Please let me know if you know a good organization in India that I could give to.
Finally, I just wanted to reiterate my heartfelt thanks, and, like thousands of your fans, I wanted to tell you what a phenomenal person you are and what a great self-less service you are doing for people in need.
May God bless! Andy.
Response from Dr. Frascino
WOO-HOO and YABBA-DABBA-DO!
Thanks for taking time to write in and share your good news and newfound insights with the forum readers. I'm confident testimonials like yours help others still stuck in their high-anxiety, worried-well hell.
Regarding your ongoing symptoms, it would be very difficult for me to diagnose the exact cause over the Internet as I do not have access to your complete medical records, a more complete history and the benefit of a physician examination. What I can do with absolute certainty over the Internet is advise that HIV is not the cause of your symptoms! Continue to follow up with a good general interest and ENT specialist and I'm confident the proper diagnosis and treatment will become manifest with further evaluation.
Thank you for your generous donation to The Robert James Frascino AIDS Foundation (www.concertedeffort.org). Your one gift will touch many lives in desperate need. On behalf of those lives, please accept my heartfelt thanks. Regarding AIDS service organizations in India, there are many. I'm reluctant to recommend one over the others, as I'm sure they all need financial help. The Robert James Frascino AIDS Foundation is currently evaluating the neediest organizations worldwide as it makes its final decisions for this year's grant recipients. I don't know yet if any programs based in India will quality to receive funds this granting cycle. The competition is extremely stiff this year as the world's economic crisis has decreased philanthropic aid to many of these worthwhile organizations.
Re: Is this ARS or something else...Please help...I want to donate Nov 27, 2010
Dr. Bob, thank you so very much for your good luck karma!! It seems like your karma has really worked. I got a DNA PCR test at day 34 and I just got the result that its negative! Two negative PCR tests at day 17 and day 34. One ve antibody test at day 28. 1) Should I whoo-hoo yet or wait for another test at 3 months?
My CD4/CD8 ratio was 690/357 = 1.9 on day 17 (based on the viral load report). The DNA PCR does not report the CD4/CD8 ratio, but says that low lymphocyte counts could result in false negative results. 2) Do you know what the threshold lymphocyte level is below which false negatives could occur? 3) Is it likely/possible that my lymphocyte levels drop that significantly from day 17 to 34 to cause a false negative DNA PCR report?
This experience has really changed my life and now I want to donate $500 to your organization once I get a conclusive result. Please don't think of this as a bribe to get your attention. You are a real hero for me After this experience, I really want to restructure my life and help out people who are not as lucky as many of us are. And secondly, I would like to get your autograph if I ever get a chance to meet you!
Kudos Dr. Bob!
Response from Dr. Frascino
Glad to hear my good-luck karma is still performing well and batting 1000.
Responding to your specific questions:
1. As I mentioned last time, your HIV-acquisition risk is so extremely remote that it's essentially negligible. The need for any HIV testing is questionable at best. Your undetectable 17-day HIV RNA PCR, negative 28-day ELISA and undetectable qualitative HIV DNA PCR at day 34 would certainly strongly suggest you are not HIV infected (as would be expected). Regarding the WOO-HOO, well, that depends on if you want a formal FDA guidelines-approved definitive result. If so, you would need to repeat your HIV-antibody test at the three-month mark, as HIV-antibody tests taken before the three-month mark are not considered conclusive and HIV DNA PCR is not FDA approved for routine HIV-diagnostic testing. I have absolutely no doubt whatsoever that your three-month test will be negative.
2. Your concerns about low lymphocyte counts affecting your HIV DNA PCR result are unwarranted. That warning applies to a very specific and quite severe condition of severely depressed lymphocytes. It certainly does not apply to you!
Thank you for your pledge to support The Robert James Frascino AIDS Foundation (www.concertedeffort.org). Your generous gift would touch many lives in desperate need. On behalf of those lives, please accept my heartfelt thanks. In return I'm sending an extra dose of my good-luck/good-health karma that you are now and will forever be HIV free!
Good luck. Happy Thanksgiving Leftovers Day.
Is this ARS or something else...Please help...I want to donate Nov 26, 2010
Dear Dr. Bob.
Firstly, my sincere thanks to you for years of dedicated service helping HIV+ people and so many scared people like me in understanding the risks and symptoms of HIV. I am re-posting this email because I did not receive an answer from you the last time with a promise to donate $100 to your foundation. I have been reading a lot on this forum and you guys have really helped me calm my nerves. Please help me diagnose my symptoms and understand my risk. Im a 29 year old married male and 6 weeks ago I had a low risk exposure at a strip club in PA. My big mistake: I went to the pvt.room and got an unprotected handjob from a stripper. There was only ONE instance when the stripper spat on her hand and used the saliva for lubrication. I did not see any visible strains of blood on my penis after the encounter, however, as the room was pretty dark (and especially after considering my symptoms), I am scared to imagine if there was really some blood in there. Also, I am uncircumcised, and after the encounter, I noticed a couple of very minor abrasions on the my penis head (due to rubbing against underwear). But again did not see any blood or anything. Historically, I have been a healthy individual, and may have been to the doctor only 2-3 times in the last 4-5 years. Here's a timeline of my symptoms after the exposure: days 9 - 12 Mild Sore throat days 14 - 15 - Diarrhea (1-2 times a day) days 15 - 24 - Loose bowels (semi-soft stools which disintegrate after being in the bowl for about 5 mins) day 27 - Unexplained bruise under my arm (could be from stretching) days 27 - 32 Reoccurrence of the Sore throat Not much phlegm or coughing, but this time with an ulcer on the back of my throat. I read that the throat ulcer is a textbook symptom of PHI, and all the symptoms combined, are really scaring me to death. Also, noticed low grade fever 99.3 couple of times. I dont know what else could cause an ulcerated sore throat and other symptoms given above. Also, I have had moderate weakness in the legs over the entire the period (days 9 32). Recently, Im feeling weakness in the arms. Although, I am able to perform all my daily activities like going to work etc. I find it difficult to walk fast for long periods or run, go to gym etc. My Tests so far: Day 5: Std Panel (HSV-2, gorronhea, etc.) - negative at day 5. Haven't yet tested for Mono. Day 17: HIV RNA PCR test - negative. Day 28: Elisa antibody test negative. Based on the symptoms, I cant help but believe that I am one of those rare cases of HIV transmission by non-typical means. I am in stress and tears almost every day. My wife is tired of convincing me that I dont have HIV. I would really appreciate some independent honest advice on how my symptoms could be that similar to HIV and fall in the same time frame, and yet, could be something else. I know you generally dont recommend PCR tests for diagnostic purpose. But specifically in my case (considering the symptoms), can you advice how much should I believe the combination of negative 17 day PCR test and 28day Elisa. Dr. Bob please, please please help me!!! I am dying of anxiety.
Response from Dr. Frascino
Your HIV-acquisition risk is negligible at best. Your symptoms are not worrisome for HIV acute retroviral syndrome (ARS). Your undetectable 17-day HIV RNA PCR and negative 28-day ELISA are encouraging, but not yet definitive.
Most of your symptoms could be related to anxiety.
You may "believe" you are "one of those rare cases of HIV transmission by non-typical means"; however, I'm quite confident that is not the case.
I suggest you seek counseling (psychotherapy) to help you cope with your anxiety and irrational HIV fears. Anti-anxiety medication may also be beneficial during the window period as you await your conclusive test results.
Get a single HIV-antibody test at the three-month mark. The result will undoubtedly be negative.
Thank you for your support of The Robert James Frascino AIDS Foundation (www.concertedeffort.org). It's warmly appreciated. In return I'm sending my good-luck karma that your definitive three-month HIV-antibody test remains negative. I'm very confident it will.
Get Email Notifications When This Forum Updates or Subscribe With RSS
This forum is designed for educational purposes only, and experts are not rendering medical, mental health, legal or other professional advice or services. If you have or suspect you may have a medical, mental health, legal or other problem that requires advice, consult your own caregiver, attorney or other qualified professional.
Experts appearing on this page are independent and are solely responsible for editing and fact-checking their material. Neither TheBody.com nor any advertiser is the publisher or speaker of posted visitors' questions or the experts' material.