Response from Dr. Sherer

This is a difficult situation that is increasingly common in resource poor settings. This young man has had more access to ART and diagnostic tests than most, but the information may well be incomplete and out of date by this time. Complex treatment courses and resistance patterns are difficult to address in this forum, because it's rarely possible to convey all of the information that I would need to make a completely well informed decision. Hence I will offer some suggestions for you and your patient to consider.
First, all HIV clinicians benefit from mentors with more experience; I would urge you to find such an individual or group in your practice setting, or via the internet, rather than this form of single question/answer dialogue, so that you can get ongoing longitudinal consultations.
All evidence suggests that some ART is better for this patient than none; hence my first suggestion is to continue ART, even in a limited form.
Your history did not mention whether he was tolerating his current medications. For his quality of life, this is critical information, and the answer might change my suggestion. In the event that such a patient is seriously ill, perhaps in part due to the side effects of the medication, I might consider reducing their ART regimen to only lamivudine (3TC), or 3TC + another NRTI, since these choices have been shown to be associated with reduced replication capacity (i.e. viral fitness), and to a less rapid decline in CD4 cells.
It is unlikely that I can select a regimen from these options that will achieve full viral suppression and reverse this young man's decline. The best that could be achieved, it appears, is to slow the rate of disease progression, and either slow the rate of CD4 cell decline, or level it. Again, my advice is limited by the lack of specific knowledge of what is available in Zambia from the list your mention, and by my lack of knowledge of this young man's past treatment history.
With full access to all current ART agents in a developed country, I would advise either darunavir or tipranavir in combination with enfurvitide (the injectable fusion inhibitor also known as T-20), Stocrin, and a new NRTI pair, likely either tenfovir or abacavir with lamivudine or emtricitabine.
Soon additional drugs will be avaialble that might help this young man in these settings, including new oral entry inhibitors like miraviroc, new second generation NNRTI such as etravirine, and new entry inhibitors such as MK-0518.
For you and your patient in Zambia, I would suggest an alternate boosted PI, e.g. boosted saquinavir or boosted fos-amprenavir, with continued Stocrin, and the NRTI combination of tenofovir or abacavir plus lamivudine.
Of course, he should also remain on SMZ prophylaxis once daily.
Unfortunately, such a change might have little impact.
At a minimum, if none of the above treatments are available to him, I would add lamivudine to his current regimen.
|