Response from Dr. Sherer

Your case provides some useful lessons in HIV
management.
First, with repeatedly undetectable viral loads
and T cells around 500, I think you are doing well
on your current regimen, and have no reason for
concern about your own status. I advise remaining
on your current regimen and continuing
periodic repeats of your T cells and viral load.
You mentioned that your doctor advised you to change
your medication. Perhaps it was for other reasons,
e.g. some previously used combinations are now
not recommended, e.g. D4T and DDI together.
Also, new long term complications have been
observed, i.e. lipodystrophy, which some
physicians are avoiding with changes in
medications. In other words, I suggest
you talk to your doctor about the reasons
that he/she advised a change.
Your genotype showed some mutations even
when the viral load was low, below detection.
Remember that the virus replicates 10 billion
times daily in a highly error-prone fashion,
such that many mutations occur regularly;
there are called 'polymorphisms.'
What your doctor is looking for with a genotypic
resistance test at a time of high viral load is
a new majority population of resistant virus
that is overgrowing wild type and causing your
regimen to fail.
We have found that resistance tests taken even
when a person's viral load is < 5 copies/ml
may show some resistance mutations, for the
reasons above. We don't know what significance
these will have in the long run, i.e. they may
just be polymorphisms that have no clinical
consequences.
Finally, its not surprising to see some
disagreement among your doctors with this data.
A more agressive approach would be to try to stay
ahead of the virus with rapid regimen changes
when mutations are observed that MAY lead to
virologic failure.
A more conservative approach would be to maintain
a regimen that is working and is well tolerated
because the next one might have side effects
that are difficult for you, and your current
regimen MAY be able to handle these mutations,
especially if they are polymorphisms rather
than the mutations of a growing dominant
population of virus. This position now seems
more likely, given your experience of the last
6 months.
While you are entitled to seek as many opinions
as you want, you can see that it doesn't always
result in complete agreement. Perhaps you can
pick the physician whose opinion you trust the
most, discuss all of these opinions with him/her,
and then follow their recommendation.
I have added the website at which to access the
IAS-USA guidelines on resistance for further information.
|