Are We Still Just Guessing?
Jun 25, 2005
Good morning Doctor,
Thanks for this very helpful and anonymous site.
I am now at 2 1/2 years off meds. I have been part of a study group since my seroconversion just over 5 years ago. This is my third and longest supervised interruption. The previous two only lasted 10 weeks each.
I have a question about the V/L tests currently being used. The PCR and the NASBA. How can they both be legitimate when they render different results from the same patient and the same blood draw? Quite accidentally the wrong test was used for my last blood draw and bore a V/L count of 29,000. When they discovered they used the wrong test, they ran the alternate test with the same blood which bore a V/L count of 9,000. This result was presented to me with a Youll be happy to hear that. Can you help me understand this disparity? Can you also help me understand why I should be happy to hear, or give more weight to the second result than the first, knowing that both are legitimate? Logic shouts that if the tests are both correct, then they are also both incorrect. This leaves me, the patient, without a point of reference. It also makes me wonder if any of these numbers really mean anything.
For the last 6 months I have been eating poorly, exercising less and smoking more. In short, my temple is a mess. Yet, according to the results of the correct test, my Ts climbed and my V/L dropped by 20K. This makes no sense to me. The results of the wrong test make more sense in the cause & effect world.
Can you help me to understand how I can use these numbers to manage my HIV infection? Or, can you direct me to a site that can? Isnt there a HIV for Dummies out yet? Or are these numbers meaningless and are we still just guessing?
Response from Dr. Holodniy
Both tests measure the same thing, plasma level of viral load. However, they use different technologies and as a consequence will have have different viral load results. That said, those results are really not that different. With most of the technologies, a 3 fold or 3 times difference would be considered assay variability regardless of the assay used. Thus, these numbers are meaningful, measure the same thing although somewhat differently, and because of assay variability are relatively close in terms of results. The most important point is stick with the same assay type and the results will always be more consistent.
Get Email Notifications When This Forum Updates or Subscribe With RSS
- Once Infected With HIV How Long Does It Take To Show Up On A Test
- Can You Die From Herpes Simplex Virus?
- Does Having Herpes Mean I Have Hiv?
- How Long Does It Take To Get Rid Of Anemia?
- Can HIV Be Transmitted Through Cut In Mouth?
- Can You Get AIDS From Unprotected Sex Without Ejaculation?
This forum is designed for educational purposes only, and experts are not rendering medical, mental health, legal or other professional advice or services. If you have or suspect you may have a medical, mental health, legal or other problem that requires advice, consult your own caregiver, attorney or other qualified professional.
Experts appearing on this page are independent and are solely responsible for editing and fact-checking their material. Neither TheBody.com nor any advertiser is the publisher or speaker of posted visitors' questions or the experts' material.